THIS COULD BE IT
Why We Ignore Perfectly Helpful Well-being Research
It makes no sense.
THIS COULD BE IT
Why We Ignore Perfectly Helpful Well-being Research
It makes no sense.
21
Why We Ignore Perfectly Helpful Well-being Research
In this episode, Mike and Jodi explore the gap between research on well-being and actual practice, discussing habits like gratitude journaling, sleep, and using personal strengths. They share humorous insights and practical ideas for integrating science into daily life to enhance happiness and fulfillment.
« We have to super prioritize and pick the big rocks for us, and be okay to give the finger to some other rocks, right? »
Jodi Wellman
Co-host
Episode Stuff
Key Topics
  • The gap between research and practice in well-being
  • Humorous take on gratitude journaling and sleep habits
  • The importance of using personal strengths in new ways
  • The impact of habits on happiness and health
  • Challenges in forming and maintaining positive habits
Chapters
  • 00:00
  • Introduction to the episode and main themes
  • 02:05
  • The reality of gratitude journaling and resistance to it
  • 04:06
  • The challenge of forming habits and the role of resistance
  • 05:16
  • The difficulty of forming habits like taking creatine or journaling
  • 06:10
  • Sleep habits and the skepticism about sleep research
  • 07:12
  • The impact of parenthood on sleep and the research on sleep cycles
  • 08:46
  • Prioritizing important tasks and the challenge of focus
  • 09:25
  • The role of research in productivity and organization
  • 10:12
  • The overwhelming list of things to do and simplifying life
  • 11:38
  • Using strengths in new ways and the research behind it
  • 12:39
  • The cycle of worry and sleep difficulty
  • 13:52
  • The idea of meaningful photos and daily reflection
  • 15:06
  • Creating artifacts of meaning and everyday mindfulness
  • 16:18
  • Reflections on gratitude and the natural disposition
  • 17:28
  • Using strengths at work and in new ways
  • 18:45
  • The importance of awareness and reflection in well-being
  • 20:39
  • The challenge of managing multiple well-being practices
  • 22:19
  • Balancing research and practical action in daily life
  • 23:31
  • The ongoing journey of figuring out how to live well
  • 24:23
  • Closing thoughts and goofy sign-off
TRANSCRIPT
Mike Steger 00:05
You're listening to this could be it, and this is a quickie. Today we are confessing a dirty, dirty, dark secret that even though we consume massive amounts of psychology and social science research, we do not always follow it. This is a podcast that generally tries to tackle why it's so difficult to just get anything moving in this complex, ever-changing, aggravating, pain-the-ass modern world.

Mike Steger 00:34
Still no flying cars, and one of the things that is bugging us today is why do we ourselves fall victim to the same traps that we are constantly trying to encourage people to jump over? Which is just apply the research. We know what will help. Why don't we do it? Today's episode, we're not going to really solve it. We're just confessing, normalizing, and you'll learn some great research on how to be happy that we completely ignore.

Jodi Wellman 01:03
Yeah, I feel like it's a confessional. Like I'm reminding myself of my youth in a confession booth. Bless me, Father, for I've sinned. Yeah. Do you know what I was gonna go with?

Jodi Wellman 01:15
How I know that I'm not supposed to drink as much alcohol as I do, but I feel like that's maybe. I think you mentioned that at every episode. I'm kidding. I'm kidding. Not every episode. That would be a real cry for help. Yeah.

Mike Steger 01:28
Gosh, guys, I'm drinking again. It's fine. I picked the wrong podcast to stop sniffing glue. Yeah, little throwback reference.

Jodi Wellman 01:37
Right as she takes another sip. Well,

Mike Steger 01:41
Brandy, you've got Brandy. I have water, delicious, clean water. I drink my eight cups a day, which is interesting. Not based on research, that number, by the way.

Jodi Wellman 01:49
Yeah, that's a bunch of baloney. Okay, I'm gonna go first.

Speaker 1 01:52
Okay,

Jodi Wellman 01:53
I am aware of the research, the gobs of it, extolling the virtues of a gratitude journal. Why are you laughing? Did I take yours?

Mike Steger 02:08
Yes.

Jodi Wellman 02:10
Shut up,

Mike Steger 02:10
jerk. Okay. Well, no, I hadn't thought of that. But the second you said, I was like, "Oh, yeah, I cannot." I practice gratitude, but like writing shit down. No, thank you.

Jodi Wellman 02:20
Well, okay.

Mike Steger 02:22
I suspect you're not actually even grateful. That's what I think. I think I'm the grateful one who just naturally, with my golden heart, goes through life appreciating butterflies, gossamer strands of spider webs, and just the beautiful spirits in every person I encounter, especially when I'm driving. That's that's what's going on here.

Jodi Wellman 02:40
Yeah, you and your gossamer. I feel like if anyone here is going to be a natural all I'm wearing, by the way,

Mike Steger 02:47
is gossamer today. I'm kidding.

Jodi Wellman 02:49
I feel like I was born grateful. Okay, and I the journal I did it at one point, so I can say I've done it, and it was nice. And I can say because I say in a lot of my talks, you know, the benefit of it, but I'm also just quoting research. You can't sit me down, and in fact, it's funny. I've got like a blank journal sitting here. I do. I'm not cracking you open. I don't even like the word journal, and we could get into all the other benefits of like journaling in general. That's like a whole other thing. What do you want to say? I can see by your face.

Mike Steger 03:21
How on earth do you not like the word journal? Is it like how some people don't like the word moist? You just don't like the way it sounds. Bad

Jodi Wellman 03:28
person.

Mike Steger 03:29
What just happened there? Do you have a moist journal, Jodi? I'm sorry. This is this sound like

Jodi Wellman 03:36
I don't think I like you anymore. I feel like journal is fine. Journal lame.

Mike Steger 03:44
gerund the gerund of journal.

Jodi Wellman 03:46
So I'm not interested in a gratitude journal. I know I could slash should do it, but now I just feel resistant. Like don't make me write out five things that I'm grateful for. Screw you. And I'm grateful for that. So what's your thing?

Mike Steger 04:01
You're grateful for your own belligerence. Well, I do have to confess, like I teach, I'm constantly teaching positive psychology and three good things or other gratitude things activities is pretty much the the activity that my students say is the most helpful. They're supposed to say it's meaning photographs, which is an activity, an intervention I created, but they are ungrateful to me, which is the worst kind of ingratitude. So yeah, but I've never even done that. I've never even done three good things for a week. Wait a minute!

Jodi Wellman 04:36
You teach it, and then you're you're a total hypocrite.

Mike Steger 04:41
Yes, of course. So I teach optimism too, like optimistic explanatory style. That that one makes me very uncomfortable. But the the students love that one too, right? I'm like, I don't, I didn't do everything that's good in my life. That makes me feel uncomfortable. Maybe just being raised in Minnesota, maybe that. There's no such thing as optimistic explanatory style for Minnesotans of a certain generation, but yeah, I haven't even done it. In part, I'm going to blame my slight attention issues in that I is impossible for me to form a habit. I mean, we've talked about this before. So habits and anything having to do with habits, or you know, other than like tooth stuff, I take care of my teeth pretty well. Even though they, I don't know, this camera always makes my teeth look like weasel teeth. I'm not really sure. I have fine teeth. Come visit them in person anytime you want, but like on camera, they look not. Do

Jodi Wellman 05:39
you bathe, Dale? Like, do you bathe? Do you are you able to keep up with that hygiene?

Mike Steger 05:44
What's the recommended scientific number of times you're supposed to bathe

Jodi Wellman 05:48
daily?

Mike Steger 05:49
That's from science.

Jodi Wellman 05:51
No, I don't know.

Mike Steger 05:52
Okay, well we're talking about research here. So when you're done doing your literature review bathing, come back to me and I'll tell you if I'm. Ladies and

Jodi Wellman 05:59
gentlemen, apparently Mike Steger, his bathing is questionable. Okay, we're gonna come back to that one.

Mike Steger 06:04
Research it's research based. So yeah, I I can't remember anything like the things, you know. So let's say you know I I want to stay fit, and I know that for me personally, if I'm if I'm active, creatine, for example, like the recommended dosage of creatine. There's no downsides. Super well researched. There are sometimes some slight intellectual benefits, cognitive benefits, but mostly it seems like you can work out a little bit harder. And for me, for whatever reason, it seems to benefit my knees, my joint, those joints in particular. Like my underneath my, I've had patellar tendonitis. I've had all these like meniscus things, and creatine helps. You would think then I just get up every day. I get up, I put the creatine in front of my coffee mug. Yeah, and I will still forget to take creatine. I cannot form a habit, so I can't be doing these like journals that require me to do anything on the daily.

Jodi Wellman 07:02
Wow! How do you think you stay employed?

Mike Steger 07:06
I'm just really, really a special boy. I'm very great at everything that involves work. Does that sound convincing?

Jodi Wellman 07:20
Yeah. Okay. So you can't form a habit. So you will not be journaling. But okay. Yeah. So you're kind of off the hook in a way because you have a cognitive disorder.

Mike Steger 07:31
So I mean, it has been diagnosed, but it's you know the way that they diagnose these things is on self-report, and I teach the DSM, so I can give my, I can make myself act out any disorder I want. I don't tend to want disorders, and I don't even care that I have this one. Although another thing, I have my Adderall, and I forget to take it. So it's just like, what's even the point? I was doing fine, doing fine. I just need a less complicated life. So simplify is something I know is supposed to do, and I try. We talked about this when we were talking. You made a crack. You like procrastination is one of the things we know is not supposed to do, but we still do. And I said, I wish I could get to the point in my life where I can procrastinate.

Jodi Wellman 08:16
I remember you said that. So one

Mike Steger 08:17
of the things I know we're supposed to do is, and I don't do enough. Is set boundaries and say no. Like focus on what is it? The jar of rocks, and you put the big rocks in first, and then the little rocks, and then the sand.

Jodi Wellman 08:31
Yeah, and then the glitter. It's

Mike Steger 08:32
all it's all pebbles to me. I don't really know what's most important, which is a strange thing for a meaning guy to say. But that is why that is that is why I keep my job. Because sorry, jump in, but like that is why I keep my job. Because generally speaking, I do spend a lot of time on the stuff that's quite important, right? Like research, thinking through the literature, writing articles and papers that hopefully are informative and interesting to read, and then almost all the rest I just get bogged down in in the dandruff of a busy working university's head, you guys say confetti, but I said dandruff. So dandruff

Jodi Wellman 09:09
worked. It's very visual. Yeah. Well, then you inherently seem to know what's important. It sounds like you got the big priorities. You do have some big rocks, but okay. Thank

Mike Steger 09:20
you.

Jodi Wellman 09:21
Oh, best of dandruff.

Mike Steger 09:24
No, no, a double entendre intended.

Jodi Wellman 09:27
None at all. What's the thing you were going to say that you skip over with the research, other than just confessing several?

Mike Steger 09:35
Yeah, there's so many, but like basically almost anything having to do with productivity, organization, prioritization, workflow stuff. I I'm sure that's all great. I should have a zero something or other zero unread inbox. I'm gonna check right now for my work email inbox right now. Stop! I have 3564 unread emails in my inbox.

Jodi Wellman 10:13
Several 100 of which are probably from me.

Mike Steger 10:16
I always read yours, Jodi. It's well, you know, so that's never gonna work. I don't do anything in particular around sleep hygiene, right? Like I do whatever I care to in my sleep space.

Jodi Wellman 10:31
Yeah,

Mike Steger 10:31
I go to sleep when I feel tired, and I wake up when I'm awake. So I, but I don't sleep that great, and I feel tired, and then I complain. But I don't follow that. I don't. I don't. I think that this sleep thing is a lie. I think it's a lie, right? Because

Jodi Wellman 10:47
by big sleep, big mattress behind it,

Mike Steger 10:50
big mattress, big hypnotists, big Ambien, like big all of it, all of it. It's all bullshit. You're saying that's my new that's my new pushback on that.

Jodi Wellman 11:04
I can't just decide if you're being silly because you or defensive because you know you can't sleep.

Mike Steger 11:10
Belligerent, belligerent, belligerent around sleep like you are around gratitude.

Jodi Wellman 11:15
I guess here's where we're different. I know gratitude more structured gratitude couldn't hurt me. It may even be better for me. So, duh. Why don't I do it? You know what I'm saying? Even I can use a different word than J U O U R N A L L I N G. So I know it's good for me. You are belligerent, or do you really know it's good for you, but you're just not figuring out how to fix it? What's what's going on with you?

Mike Steger 11:41
All right, so here's the deal. Before I became a parent, I was fine at sleeping. Then I became a parent, and I've never heard anyone say that your kids permanently destroy your ability to sleep. You know, but you kind of enter this weird hyper vigilant state for years, right? Noises or lack of noises, crazy schedules, no time to relax, and I think the biggest here's here is now here is research that I think explains why big sleep is BS, right? Because if you worry about whether you're going to get to sleep or not, that easily triggers anxious cognitive cycles, right? And it activates mild alarm symptoms. You don't feel right, then you can't sleep. Then you observe yourself not sleeping. You're like, oh fuck, I guess I'm not sleeping tonight. And like, oh my god, but I've got so many things in the morning. Plus, if I don't sleep eight hours a day, I will die at age 32, which is coming up for me, as we all know. So this is this is. I would much rather take the hit on whatever BS they've dreamed up for the long term consequences of getting not perfect sleep than worry about it, because I think in the end it'll prevent me from sleeping anyways. Okay, that does

Jodi Wellman 12:59
seem sound. I get you. Can I challenge you? Just because now I feel like I can't, I can't have any of your students take your classes in the future and know that you are just a. You can't

Mike Steger 13:12
have any of my students take my class,

Jodi Wellman 13:15
and and know that you're. You need to

Mike Steger 13:16
send anyone any any of your young mentees to college. I'm saying I can't. I don't

Jodi Wellman 13:21
want to. I I will lose sleep at night knowing that your students may become aware that you're a hypocrite. So what if what if I pinged you once a day for a week or 10 days? What's what is the intervention to do? Or even if it's the the this photo thing you said you invented, if you can't structure your life, other people could. I could ping you and be like, "Do it now." And then, if you did it, would that be beneficial?

Mike Steger 13:47
I do do the photo thing. What do you do? Meaningful photo. You just like take a photo intentionally and mindfully. Take a photo of something that represents what makes your life meaningful. Oh, Jodi is taking a picture of herself. No,

Jodi Wellman 14:04
fuck you! I did the picture of the screen, and the best part is that you, if you're not watching on YouTube, which everybody should be watching on YouTube, where you should also subscribe, like, and donate. Not that there's an ability to donate, but we'll find out.

Mike Steger 14:16
Oh yeah, sponsor. We're still hoping for Jelly Pig, the amazing off-brand vacuum cleaner maker.

Jodi Wellman 14:24
I would do Jelly Belly, Jelly Beans. Anything with

Mike Steger 14:27
Jelly.

Jodi Wellman 14:28
So your meaningful photo. Back to the meaningful photo. You just take a meaningful photo, and then what do you do?

Mike Steger 14:34
Well, you the the heart of this idea is that how do you know what to take a picture of, unless you're thinking through in your life, in your daily life, what is meaningful.

Jodi Wellman 14:47
Okay,

Mike Steger 14:48
right. So that's actually that's actually the judo trick of the intervention. Not to give it away, but you can't do this intervention unless you reflect on what makes your life meaningful.

Jodi Wellman 15:00
Okay,

Mike Steger 15:00
and then you go out and you do it, and then you can't be griping all the time. Yeah, I can only gripe most of the time because I see like my life is filled with meaningful things, like a little, a very cool little eddy in a stream, or a leaf that looks like it's kicking ass, or the mountains, or you know, if you are watching on YouTube, which which we kind of assume you are, because we're staring at each other, so we assume that you might be staring at us too. But wherever you, wherever you subscribe, if you do ever check us out on YouTube, you'll see over my shoulder there's actually a framed potato chip bag. I I brought that bag from Hong Kong, and it's framed and meaningful to me.

Jodi Wellman 15:43
Why?

Mike Steger 15:45
Well, we we'll have to get into that a different time. No, damn. But you know, like it's a way it's a way of of populating and endowing your life with meaning, because it creates artifacts of meaning. Okay, this Rosicrucian rituals.

Speaker 2 16:01
Rosicrucian.

Mike Steger 16:02
I know.

Jodi Wellman 16:02
you ever have students come to you and say, "I took zero photos this week because there was no meeting" ?

Mike Steger 16:11
I don't know.

Jodi Wellman 16:12
All right.

Mike Steger 16:13
I don't know if they come to me and say that. You know, they they might put that in their assignments because they can choose. They don't have to do that one. So the way I run this has a lot of choice because I follow that research on how to design effective interventions. But no, Jodi. Okay, I don't believe that you were born grateful, but that's okay because no baby is. Babies are born greedy and selfish.

Jodi Wellman 16:37
He's being technical people. Okay.

Mike Steger 16:40
So what? What else? Now I've confessed a million. What's another one? Using my strengths in a new way.

Jodi Wellman 16:49
Oh, okay.

Mike Steger 16:50
Not Peterson

Jodi Wellman 16:51
at all.

Mike Steger 16:52
Yeah, I don't. That's actually like using your strengths at work. Lots of research. I think I do that. My strengths are mainly going off topic and occasionally making a crass comment. So those are my two top strengths: an appreciation of beauty and curiosity, love of learning, kindness, which most people don't believe. Yeah, and humor. So I do use my strengths at work, but using them in a new way like that feels like a lot of work, and I'll pass. Yeah,

Jodi Wellman 17:19
yeah. I recognize the the stats, isn't it? That if you're aware of your strengths, you're 10 times likelier to be flourishing. Okay, so you are. Yay! 10 times good for you. And if you use them in new way,

Mike Steger 17:30
before they invented character strengths, was I just

Jodi Wellman 17:33
you? You were just floundering, flopping around, floundering, not happy. So then, when you realized, wow, there's this assessment I can take, and now I know what my strengths are. You shot up 10 times, but

Mike Steger 17:44
10 times, yeah. If

Jodi Wellman 17:45
17 times is the stat associated with using your strengths in new ways, and so I also this is from

Mike Steger 17:52
Gallup. I'm guessing maybe

Jodi Wellman 17:54
no. This is from Via.

Mike Steger 17:56
17 times more flourishing if I use my strengths.

Jodi Wellman 18:01
If you use your strengths in in new ways, like if you find ways to maximize them, so for example, so

Mike Steger 18:07
if I scored a five out of seven on some subjective well being scale, and I use my strengths in new way, I would score 85 out of seven on the scale.

Jodi Wellman 18:21
This is not a time for interrogation of their methodology of the research here. I don't know what you're doing to me. I'm telling you the fucking stats of how the point is. I'm backing you up to illustrate how you're horrible, which is what you're trying to say. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Mike Steger 18:35
That's what we're trying to say. Is I'm which is

Jodi Wellman 18:37
you know it's good for you to use your strengths in new and interesting ways, and the point is, you're saying you're not, and yeah, I don't really do that either. Why do we not? Okay, why do you think we don't do that?

Mike Steger 18:49
Man, life's busy. Like the list of things to do. This is part of the issue. So I, I do have a saving grace for all this sort of stuff, right? The list of things, like I'm, I'm. I just wrote a book, and it'll be coming out in February 2027 called "The Present Meaning" with Oxford University Press, which reviews all the meaning literature and gives behind-the-scenes glimpses of what it was like to create that research. Since I'm a leading voice there, and it gives away a few cool ideas about what you can do for creating more meaning in your life. That book is going to be hundreds of pages long. I also have another book coming out in 2027 about purpose. This will be coming out with 10 Speed Press, so it's a little bit more of an airport book for the everyday personal. Although I think you'll like the Oxford one is written in a very non academic tone. I like make lots of jokes. Most of them don't work, but comedy is a volume business, as we all know. And there's probably like, especially the book I'm writing for 10 Speed Press with Todd Cashin has probably like 100 exercises. Oof! Wow, it seems like. And you know you add that to the other book, and then you add that to the books that have exercises that we don't include or I don't include, and that's just in the meaning and purpose space. Then you say, I also want character strength stuff, and I also want gratitude, and I also want mindfulness, and I also want self compassion, and I also want I don't know, make some stuff up,

Jodi Wellman 20:19
health,

Mike Steger 20:20
like big, big honking muscles. I don't know, non-yellow teeth. You know, I don't want wrinkles on my forehead. It's very funny. I had these. I was see. You were born with gratitude. I was born frowning like this.

Jodi Wellman 20:33
Okay, not like that.

Mike Steger 20:35
So there's just too much, and we keep pushing more into people's laps that they're supposed to do. So I actually think it's a good thing if we decide we're gonna tell some of this stuff to take a hike. But we still have to keep telling people that stuff because we get distracted and we forget what we're supposed to be doing. Be happy.

Jodi Wellman 20:55
Yeah, the giant pile of shoulds does feel overwhelming, and if you add it up all together, it is maybe impossible to do all the things we're supposed to do. Like if anyone really added that up, who's living that life? So now we have to be super judicious. We have to be super prioritize and pick the big rocks for us, and be okay to give the finger to some other rocks, right? Like sleep for you, or and maybe what we're doing. I think what what I'm catching in our conversation, which maybe is slightly useful for anybody and myself, is like we could take a kernel of an idea and still have that be okay. Like I don't need to journal the things that make me feel grateful, but if I'm conscious that oh right, like in a moment, I should stop and make sure that I don't take this mountain for granted. And I look at and go, "Wow, that is really beautiful." I feel so lucky. I get to live and see this. That's good. Like I don't have to go home and write it in a very special fountain pen. So it's like you can take little bits and pieces of it, right? So maybe that is part of it. If we identify the same thing with the health, if you want big honking muscles, well, maybe you're not gonna have the time to do that, but at least you could do one good thing for your health, like maybe lift a can three times. You know?

Mike Steger 22:08
Yep, a can. Starting ambitious. Well, okay. So here's I'll say a few things, right? Because we have to talk about this topic at some point, also, which is why this the double sided coin. Side number one has why don't we do the things we know are good for us? Because none of us do all of it, and a lot of us do shit that we know is very bad for us, and we nothing can stop us out of control. Part number two is why do we keep needing podcasts like this, or books, or new research? You know, a lot a lot of times we're just adding to the list, and sometimes we're adding to a list stuff that people already kind of know, like sleep. For example, no one opts in or out of sleep, and I don't need, you know, big sleep telling me that I need sleep because my body tells me that, right? So, what what does research on sleep actually do for us then? Well, you know, it puts it back on the list of things that maybe we should take a a moment to take to remind ourselves of. And so, this is part of what we're part of the thing that I think we're going to continually perseverate over, Jodi, is that we're never done figuring out how to live best in this crazy kooky modern world. The world changes, we change, our attention changes, what's on our to-do lists changes, the things we think are big rocks in the jar change, and so we just need to be able to keep coming back to the river, bathing ourselves with excellent hygiene, as we all know, seven times a day. Yeah, right. So that's that's why we got to have this research. That's why we have to have these conversations, and that's why it's got to be okay sometimes to say, "All right, research is there, but I'm still not going to do

Jodi Wellman 23:58
it." Amen. And I want us all to use the word perseverate within the next week. Let's just all find a way to do that, okay?

Mike Steger 24:05
And journaling.

Jodi Wellman 24:08
You're the worst. This could be it. Literally, this podcast episode could be it.

Mike Steger 24:13
Might have gone too far.
© 2026 All Rights Reserved